Center for Media Justice home of the Media Action Grassroots Network

One Size Does Not Fit All: A Slippery Slope to Increased Juvenile Incarceration

The following is a guest blog by James Bell, Founder and Executive Director of the W. Haywood Burns Institute. HBI and Community Justice Network for Youth are partners in CMJ’s Racial Justice Framing Project.

*Pacifica’s Mitch Jesserich spoke to James about reauthorization of the JJDPA and the BI’s new report!

A recent incident in Omaha, Nebraska brings urgency to an issue soon to be debated in Congress regarding the handling of youth offenders by juvenile and criminal justice systems. In this case, police shot a 15-year-old boy in the chest following a traffic stop. Investigators said the boy shot at police first. The case has led one local senator to call for an overhaul of Nebraska’s juvenile justice system that would identify “aggressive juvenile offenders.”

This is a dangerous reaction to a singular incident. But it is not uncommon. Politicians often legislate by anecdote. When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

When one examines this case further, it becomes clear that for Nebraska State Sen. Brad Ashford to use this particular incident as an example of why the city’s “most aggressive juvenile offenders need to be more readily identified,” is a slippery slope. Ashford told an Omaha television station that he is working on legislation that would do just that.

“The best way to unclog the juvenile court system, and the best way to prevent violence amongst juveniles, is to catch these young people early as they exhibit behaviors that indicate they will very likely shoot somebody someday,” Ashford told KETV Omaha.

There is no evidence that any justice system can viably identify and “catch” potential violent offenders. Indeed, years of reactive legislation by politicians demonstrate that just because they have a bully pulpit and power does not make them informed, thoughtful or effective. In fact, Sen. Ashford’s efforts could actually result in an increase in the use of incarceration for juveniles and adult lock-ups. This is an alarming reaction for those who use data to drive policy and practice. Research shows that youth confined in adult jails and lock-ups are more likely to re-offend upon release and while confined are at pronounced high risk of suffering assault and committing suicide.

Congress is expected to soon consider the reauthorization of the federal Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Reauthorization Act (JJDPA), which among many provisions that ensure protection for youth in juvenile and criminal justice systems, would help to keep youth awaiting trial in criminal court out of adult lock-up and ensure “sight and sound separation” in the limited circumstances where they are held in adult facilities. This is sound public policy. Any rational civil society values the separations of young people and adults in confinement. If reauthorized, the JJDPA would also permit States to continue to house and rehabilitate youth convicted in adult court in juvenile facilities until they reach a certain age.

But sound legislation based on data and research is often threatened by political rhetoric and emotional reaction, as we have seen across the country in our work to reduce racial and ethnic disparities in local juvenile justice systems. In this particular case, Omaha’s police union president, Aaron Hanson, responded to the incident by saying the case and others like it have “to do with the fact that many of these youthful violent offenders are sent through the juvenile justice system, as opposed to the adult criminal justice system.”

This is a familiar line of thought that is woefully inaccurate. Such thinking was first popularized by in the late eighties by John Dilulio, a Princeton political scientist who coined the phrase “super-predators.” Soon thereafter, politicians and the media adopted this phrase and ushered in an avalanche of draconian laws based on anecdote and worse-case scenarios rather than actual data or research. Those laws remain today and are responsible for the notion of “throw-away” youth. We do not increase public safety by using detention early and often for young people in trouble with the law.

This particular case should be handled individually, applying the facts and the law, and not as a launching pad for legislative short-term gain. Today, a majority of youth in detention are incarcerated for minor and nonviolent offenses. Two-thirds of youth in detention are youth of color, though they are only one-third of the total U.S. youth population. In other words, African American youth are 5.5 times more likely to be detained than White youth, while Latino youth and Native American youth are both 2.5 times more likely to be detained than White youth.

The JJDPA reflects a better approach. When passed, it would limit the amount of time that juveniles are detained for “nondelinquent status offenses,” such as truancy, running away or violating curfew, alcohol and tobacco laws. Its other vital provisions include increasing financial incentives for States to improve diversion programs for youth with mental health and substance abuse needs; directing States to develop policies and procedures to eliminate the use of isolation and restraints, and to enhance alternatives to detention and transitional services.

Importantly, the JJDPA would also direct States and localities to actively work to reduce racial and ethnic disparities. Today, research demonstrates that youth of color are incarcerated more often than White youth even when charged with the same category of offense. Currently, the JJDPA requires States to “address” disparities within the juvenile justice system, but it does not require oversight of reduction efforts, accurate collection of relevant data, development of work plans with measurable objectives, or regular monitoring, evaluation, and reporting.

We hope that this bill will move through the Senate Judiciary Committee and to the floor of the Senate before the end of the year. And we trust that the Senate will do everything within its power to preserve the prevention focus of the JJDPA by guarding against any amendments that would link the JJDPA to provisions or other forms of federal legislation that introduce new federal categories of juvenile crime, new or enhanced federal penalties affecting juveniles, or incentives for States to advance new or enhanced penalties for juveniles.

How long are we as a nation going to allow justice policy to be determined by anecdote, storytelling and worst-case scenarios? When are we as a society going to pierce the veil of supposedly “tough on crime” legislation? If and when we do, we will find that we are a safer and more productive society by being “smart on crime.” That means allowing the court system to do its job for violent crimes, while not over-reacting with blanket legislation to any dramatic incident that grabs media attention. We must act now to ensure the best outcomes for our future generations.

About the Author

Comments

  1. I simply needed to thank you very much once more. I’m not certain the things I would’ve taken care of in the absence of the basics contributed by you relating to that theme. Certainly was a very scary issue in my position, nevertheless viewing this skilled manner you managed it made me to jump over delight. I will be thankful for this work and thus expect you realize what a great job you happen to be undertaking training the rest by way of a blog. Most probably you’ve never encountered any of us.

  2. Thanks so much for giving everyone an exceptionally brilliant opportunity to read articles and blog posts from here. It is usually very good and packed with a good time for me and my office mates to search your site a minimum of three times weekly to learn the new things you have got. Not to mention, I’m so actually motivated with the good pointers you serve. Some 2 tips in this posting are indeed the most beneficial we’ve ever had.

  3. kyrie 4 says:

    Thanks for your entire efforts on this blog. My daughter takes pleasure in conducting investigations and it’s simple to grasp why. A number of us notice all concerning the compelling tactic you provide invaluable items by means of the web blog and therefore strongly encourage participation from some other people on the concern so our favorite child is without a doubt learning a lot of things. Have fun with the rest of the new year. You are doing a stunning job.

  4. yeezy 500 says:

    I precisely wanted to thank you so much again. I am not sure the things I might have created in the absence of the entire suggestions provided by you regarding that area. Previously it was a very frightful crisis in my opinion, however , viewing the professional fashion you solved the issue took me to cry for fulfillment. Now i’m grateful for the help and then believe you find out what an amazing job you’re getting into instructing the others by way of your webpage. Most likely you’ve never met all of us.

  5. I simply had to say thanks once again. I’m not certain the things I might have worked on in the absence of these hints documented by you regarding such a topic. This was the distressing crisis for me, nevertheless spending time with this expert way you treated the issue made me to weep for happiness. Now i am happy for this help and then have high hopes you comprehend what an amazing job you were getting into training the mediocre ones through a site. Most likely you’ve never met any of us.

  6. Thanks for your entire efforts on this blog. Debby really likes going through investigations and it’s really easy to see why. All of us notice all of the dynamic medium you give reliable techniques via your blog and boost contribution from other ones about this situation then our simple princess is truly understanding so much. Take pleasure in the remaining portion of the new year. You’re carrying out a brilliant job.

  7. I am just writing to make you know of the brilliant encounter our princess experienced studying your web page. She picked up too many pieces, with the inclusion of what it is like to have a marvelous giving mindset to let many people effortlessly fully grasp certain extremely tough subject matter. You truly surpassed our own expected results. Many thanks for distributing the invaluable, dependable, explanatory not to mention unique tips about the topic to Janet.

  8. adidas nmd says:

    I truly wanted to post a quick word to be able to express gratitude to you for all the magnificent facts you are giving here. My considerable internet search has at the end of the day been compensated with reasonable concept to go over with my great friends. I would believe that we visitors actually are extremely fortunate to live in a decent place with so many lovely professionals with interesting techniques. I feel extremely happy to have come across your entire web pages and look forward to so many more awesome times reading here. Thank you again for all the details.

  9. yeezy shoes says:

    I must show my affection for your generosity for folks who require guidance on your matter. Your very own dedication to getting the message all-around came to be extraordinarily good and have without exception empowered people like me to achieve their targets. Your new warm and helpful instruction indicates a lot to me and still more to my peers. Best wishes; from everyone of us.

  10. I am glad for writing to make you know what a exceptional encounter my wife’s daughter enjoyed reading through your site. She came to find some pieces, which include what it is like to possess a wonderful helping style to make others completely thoroughly grasp a number of extremely tough matters. You really did more than our own expectations. Thank you for providing those powerful, trustworthy, educational not to mention cool guidance on the topic to Mary.

  11. Thanks a lot for providing individuals with such a special chance to read articles and blog posts from this website. It’s always so nice plus stuffed with a lot of fun for me and my office friends to visit the blog a minimum of 3 times in 7 days to study the newest issues you will have. And indeed, I am at all times pleased concerning the effective methods you serve. Certain 1 tips in this post are definitely the most impressive we have all had.

  12. I simply wanted to thank you very much again. I am not sure what I would have followed without the type of points revealed by you directly on my topic. It seemed to be the difficult situation in my position, nevertheless observing a new well-written avenue you solved it made me to leap with gladness. I’m happy for this information as well as hope that you really know what an amazing job that you’re providing teaching some other people thru a site. Most probably you haven’t encountered all of us.

  13. Thanks so much for providing individuals with an extremely remarkable chance to read in detail from this blog. It can be very excellent and stuffed with a lot of fun for me personally and my office peers to visit your blog minimum thrice in a week to learn the latest guides you will have. And indeed, I am usually amazed for the special knowledge served by you. Some two ideas in this posting are really the simplest we have all had.

  14. I am glad for writing to let you understand of the amazing experience my cousin’s girl enjoyed studying your webblog. She mastered some pieces, which include how it is like to possess an excellent helping mood to let the rest smoothly gain knowledge of specified multifaceted matters. You actually surpassed readers’ expected results. Many thanks for showing these great, safe, revealing and easy guidance on the topic to Evelyn.

  15. I would like to express my thanks to the writer just for bailing me out of this particular circumstance. After surfing around through the the net and finding advice which were not helpful, I was thinking my entire life was gone. Being alive without the answers to the issues you’ve resolved through your entire site is a critical case, and ones which could have negatively damaged my career if I had not encountered the website. Your primary understanding and kindness in taking care of the whole lot was priceless. I don’t know what I would’ve done if I had not encountered such a subject like this. I can also at this moment look forward to my future. Thank you so much for this reliable and sensible help. I will not be reluctant to suggest the sites to any person who should have counselling about this subject matter.

  16. jordan retro says:

    I truly wanted to post a brief comment so as to say thanks to you for all of the unique tips you are placing at this website. My rather long internet search has at the end been recognized with really good tips to write about with my best friends. I ‘d repeat that many of us readers actually are really lucky to live in a remarkable website with very many perfect individuals with very beneficial methods. I feel somewhat blessed to have seen your entire web site and look forward to so many more thrilling minutes reading here. Thanks once again for everything.

  17. vans shoes says:

    Thanks so much for giving everyone remarkably brilliant opportunity to read critical reviews from here. It can be very ideal and full of amusement for me and my office mates to search your blog minimum thrice in one week to study the latest guides you have got. Of course, I am also certainly satisfied concerning the dazzling information you serve. Selected 1 points in this posting are completely the most suitable I have had.

  18. I enjoy you because of every one of your effort on this web site. Betty really likes managing internet research and it is obvious why. We know all relating to the dynamic mode you convey powerful tips and tricks via the web blog and inspire contribution from other people about this issue plus my child has always been studying a lot. Take pleasure in the rest of the new year. You’re the one conducting a glorious job.

  19. gucci belts says:

    Thank you for your whole hard work on this website. Gloria really likes conducting investigation and it is simple to grasp why. A number of us hear all of the compelling medium you provide reliable guidelines through your web site and in addition cause participation from some others on that subject then our child is undoubtedly becoming educated so much. Have fun with the rest of the new year. You’re the one performing a wonderful job.

  20. I precisely needed to thank you so much once more. I am not sure the things that I would have made to happen without the actual solutions revealed by you relating to my problem. It absolutely was a intimidating situation for me, but looking at a well-written avenue you resolved that made me to weep over fulfillment. Now i am happier for the advice and thus trust you find out what a great job you are getting into educating some other people through the use of your web page. I know that you’ve never come across any of us.

  21. I wish to voice my love for your kind-heartedness giving support to men and women who need help on in this area of interest. Your special dedication to getting the solution along turned out to be wonderfully informative and has usually enabled professionals like me to get to their aims. Your entire important guidelines indicates so much to me and additionally to my mates. Thanks a lot; from everyone of us.

  22. foamposites says:

    I really wanted to post a simple note so as to thank you for the marvelous tips you are posting on this site. My extensive internet lookup has at the end been honored with extremely good concept to share with my best friends. I ‘d declare that many of us readers are very lucky to exist in a fabulous site with very many wonderful professionals with very beneficial ideas. I feel pretty privileged to have encountered the web page and look forward to really more cool times reading here. Thank you once again for all the details.

  23. goyard tote says:

    I just wanted to post a word to be able to thank you for some of the amazing tactics you are giving on this site. My long internet look up has now been rewarded with wonderful details to go over with my family members. I would believe that most of us website visitors are truly endowed to be in a good network with very many marvellous professionals with insightful basics. I feel truly grateful to have encountered your entire web page and look forward to some more fabulous moments reading here. Thanks a lot once more for a lot of things.

  24. kd 10 says:

    I want to show my love for your kindness for those individuals that absolutely need help on this one matter. Your real dedication to passing the message all over appears to be incredibly good and has continuously made girls like me to achieve their dreams. The invaluable guidelines indicates so much to me and somewhat more to my colleagues. With thanks; from each one of us.

  25. I precisely wished to appreciate you again. I’m not certain the things I might have followed without the entire creative concepts documented by you concerning such a question. It seemed to be a real fearsome matter for me, but noticing the skilled tactic you processed that forced me to cry with happiness. I will be happy for this help as well as have high hopes you recognize what a great job you have been doing instructing some other people via your webpage. Most likely you’ve never got to know all of us.

  26. I and also my buddies appeared to be studying the great suggestions on your web site while before long I had an awful feeling I had not thanked the web site owner for those strategies. Most of the men happened to be very interested to read through them and already have surely been making the most of them. I appreciate you for actually being really accommodating and then for making a decision on these kinds of decent subject matter most people are really wanting to discover. Our sincere apologies for not expressing gratitude to sooner.

  27. nhl jerseys says:

    I am commenting to make you know what a terrific encounter my girl encountered browsing your site. She mastered a lot of details, including how it is like to possess an awesome coaching mindset to get other individuals smoothly learn specific multifaceted topics. You actually exceeded readers’ desires. I appreciate you for presenting those productive, dependable, edifying and also fun tips about this topic to Mary.

  28. I needed to write you a very small remark so as to say thank you once again for all the nice opinions you’ve shared on this site. It’s certainly remarkably generous with people like you in giving openly all a lot of folks would have offered for sale for an ebook to get some money on their own, mostly considering the fact that you could have tried it in the event you considered necessary. The guidelines likewise served to become a easy way to be aware that many people have a similar passion just as mine to figure out whole lot more with reference to this matter. I am certain there are several more pleasant occasions in the future for many who scan your blog post.

  29. Thank you for your entire hard work on this website. My aunt take interest in doing investigations and it’s really obvious why. I know all about the powerful form you present priceless techniques through the blog and as well increase contribution from visitors about this subject matter while our daughter is being taught a lot of things. Take pleasure in the remaining portion of the new year. You’re carrying out a fantastic job.

  30. I must express some appreciation to you just for rescuing me from this particular matter. Just after checking throughout the internet and coming across advice which were not powerful, I figured my life was well over. Being alive devoid of the strategies to the issues you have solved by means of the posting is a crucial case, and those that could have adversely damaged my career if I hadn’t encountered your web blog. Your own mastery and kindness in taking care of all the pieces was very helpful. I am not sure what I would have done if I had not discovered such a step like this. I am able to now look forward to my future. Thank you very much for the high quality and results-oriented guide. I will not be reluctant to suggest your web blog to anybody who should get support about this topic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Website by Radish Lab.