Center for Media Justice home of the Media Action Grassroots Network

The Internet Must Not Become a Segregated Online Community

By Malkia Cyril, Chris Rabb, and Joseph Torres

When Fox News’ Glenn Beck called President Barack Obama a racist this past July, the online advocacy group launched a campaign to convince advertisers to boycott the show. To date, some 285,000 people have joined the effort, and more than 80 companies have pulled their ads.

CNN parted ways with Lou Dobbs last month after civil rights groups and mobilized thousands of Latinos online to call on CNN to dump the talk show host for spewing hate against immigrants for years.
None of this—not these advocacy efforts, not countless small business success stories, not even the election of President Obama—would have happened without a free and open Internet. For communities of color, the Internet provides us with a unique opportunity to speak for ourselves without first seeking approval or permission or having to secure major funds to do so. But the big telecommunications companies like AT&T, Verizon and Comcast want to create an effectively segregated online community where they will act as our gatekeepers.

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is now considering new rules that could protect the fundamental principle of “Network Neutrality” once and for all. Net Neutrality prohibits Internet service providers (ISPs) from blocking, discriminating against or deterring Internet users from accessing online content and applications of their choice—such as e-newsletters, blogs, social networking sites, online videos, podcasts and smart-phone apps.

It’s not that network owners are secretly plotting to stifle free speech. But they have an undeniable, rational interest in creating a pay-for-play model for the treatment of communication on the Internet. Commercial Web sites that pay will get speed and quality, and the noncommercial uses of the Net will be collateral damage—relegated to the slow lane. It’s not necessarily that they want to block our speech for political reasons. It’s that our speech is not important to them because it’s not going to make them money.

The Internet provides our communities with a medium to access services, find jobs, connect to friends, make inexpensive international phone calls to family members, and to advocate for social change. Many of the most valuable things we do online are noncommercial; they exist because the Internet is the first mass media system with no gatekeepers to dole out privilege to the highest bidder. That freedom and openness is what makes the Internet different from broadcasting and cable. We can’t allow Comcast, AT&T, Verizon and other broadband providers to deliver substandard Internet service to our communities.

Telecom Companies Want to Create Second-Class “Netizens”
But the big phone and cable companies want to get rid of Net Neutrality and control how the public accesses the Internet.

This threat to Internet freedom isn’t hypothetical. Verizon got caught blocking text messages sent by the pro-choice group NARAL to its own members – backing down only in response to public pressure. Comcast has also illegally interfered with file-sharing on its network, a practice that earned the company a rebuke from the FCC.

Even though President Obama pledged that he would “take a back seat to no one” on Net Neutrality, the big phone and cable companies are pulling out all the stops to derail it, including deploying Karl Rove-style scare tactics within our communities and using their massive resources to block Obama’s agenda.

In the first nine months of 2009, they employed nearly 500 lobbyists and spent some $74 million to influence Congress and the FCC. Their misinformation has even convinced Glenn Beck that Net Neutrality is an attempt by President Obama to take over the Internet.

Who will protect the online rights of marginalized communities against the raw profit motive of big business? We urge leaders not to yield to the underhanded scare tactics that corporations like AT&T have used on our communities.

We Must Reject a Separate but Unequal Online World
One of those scare tactics is the claim, pushed by phone and cable companies, that Network Neutrality poses a threat to digital inclusion. Nothing could be further from the truth. Not only does Net Neutrality expand media diversity and access by ensuring fairness and nondiscrimination by big corporations, it will prevent the kind of media consolidation that has happened in the broadcast industry by helping our communities develop a diversity of civic and commercial online enterprises on a scale that represents our growing online numbers.

A primary reason for the digital divide is that the cost of fully engaging in the online world is just too high for many in our communities. Broadband in the United States is among the slowest but most expensive of any industrialized nation. After years of consolidation, the largest telecom companies have gotten away with price-gouging our communities because of a lack of competition in the broadband market.

More choices for broadband service—not permitting more discrimination—are the key to bringing down costs. Scrapping Net Neutrality in order to consolidate control over the Internet by cable and phone companies is not the answer. More market control won’t give them more incentive to sell low-cost high-quality services to low-income communities. Our communities will still be subject to the same business logic that has marginalized us in the first place since our households don’t have a lot of money to spend. Shareholders aren’t charities, and we are foolish to expect otherwise.

But more importantly, we should not be sacrificing an open Internet to bribe phone and cable companies not to practice forms of red-lining. The answer to the digital divide cannot be to deliver a second-class, closed Internet to our communities.

The historic fight against discrimination by groups like the NAACP and the League of United Latin American Citizens has led to great societal change, laying the groundwork for the election of a president of color. We urge our colleagues in the civil rights community to fight with us to ensure that telecom and cable companies are not allowed to discriminate against our communities or interfere with our capacity to speak for ourselves without first asking AT&T, Verizon or Comcast for permission.

So far, several organizations of color have spoken out in favor of passing Net Neutrality regulations, including the National Hispanic Media Coalition, UNITY: Journalists of Color and
We are living through a critical moment in our nation’s history. The FCC is going to decide whether the Internet will remain an open platform that allows for the greatest number of voices to participate in our democratic society, or whether it will be a closed network controlled by the big telecom companies.

We are concerned about the dire consequences of living without Net Neutrality. It would create a separate but unequal online world where our communities will be unable to use the Internet to compete or to advocate for justice when we have been wronged.

We need civil rights, media justice, community-oriented and grassroots organizations to stand together to make sure effective Net Neutrality regulation will protect our communities from the predatory practices of the phone and cable companies.

As with past civil rights struggles that successfully expanded access, thwarted discrimination, destroyed legalized segregation, and created broad opportunity, so too will the cause of Internet freedom.

Malkia Cyril is the executive director of the Center for Media Justice. Chris Rabb is the founder of the online community Afro-Netizen and is a visiting researcher at the Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs at Princeton University. Joseph Torres is the government relations manager of Free Press and former deputy director of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists.

About the Author


  1. queenying says:

    Evening dresses
    With more 1000 Designer dresses,we supply Evening Dresses,Custom Dresses,formal gowns,cocktail dresses with wholesale price
    prom dresses
    Dresses, evening, cocktail, prom dresses, formal gowns from dresseslife. Homecoming dresses and bridesmaid
    Graduation Dresses
    Looking For discount Balenciaga handbags? The store online sells the Balenciaga bags.
    Welcome to visit and buy Balenciaga handbags. we offer Balenciaga Handbags,Balenciaga
    Balenciaga Handbags
    Balenciaga sale

  2. Billy says:

    Money doesn’t grow on trees. On top of all of the perqs of unsecured no credit check loans to pay bail bond agents, there tend to be a small number of cons involved with bail bond loans that do not require credit checks, (See, that you should consider in advance of applying for a loan. Compared to different types of financing, the APR from the short term financing can be crazy high! Pretend you could have obtained $525, the price tag might be as high as $60 which can be considered quite pricey. Additionally this monetary fee will probably continue to accrue in the event the consumer is not able to pay the advance right away when it comes payable. This is ripe for abuse Failing to pay on a no credit check loan to pay the bail bond fees will not impact your credit standing, nevertheless this is no defense for individuals getting over on the system to repay the financial obligation to the bail bond companies!

  3. qrs521 says:

    When woman go out, they never forget to take women bags with her in many occasions ,in the earliest time , carrying a women handbag just bring a convenience for woman to keep change, keys, cellphones, credit cards, lipstick and other makeup, comb, pens, and all the other make up things . and then, it become a fishion decoration ,sometimes it just a fashion accessory, Ladies with different cheap bags will give you different impressions, So a beautiful lady should have many different handbags to match different occasions. So women, I want to give a piece of advice, you really need to own different new women bags> that are in different colors , different style and different size.

    Women bags sale should match well with the clothes and shoes they , and match well the occasion, so you need different style<women handbags sale, and I believe you must don’t want to be out of fashion, so the new style is a must, Women Handbags Sale if you want to catch up with the fishion, you need to come to our store often, we can give you a sight of fishion.I think authentic Louis Vuitton Handbags and Gucci bags are too expensive.New women bags sale online is very convenient for you to choose your favorite bags .Women New Bags.
    We have a reliable replica cheap bags on sale that can give you a high quality replica cheap handbags , New women bags sale online and the price is reasonable. The design and quality of the bags are excellent. That’s because the materials we use are in good quality.
    UGG boots cardy for some fans are the only other option for online auctions uggs sites.Unfortunately offer at this time of year, just over the brand new women uggs for less money. Due to the demand, new women uggs probably sold in their pricing. Many know that Classic Tall Ugg Boots not the cheapest shoes in the city. During the shopping season, UGG boots short you should expect to pay more than a hundred dollars for a new pair of uggs This is the perfect time for sellers to their peers because of frustrated fans definitely become Classic Short Ugg Boots auction auction sites, if Short ugg boots can not find what they are doing in the regular pages.
    When you have one pair of women ugg boots , you may love wearing them all the time . Uggs are made of sheepskin materials to keep warm, so that you could wear Ugg boots tall in winter even in rainy days, which could keep your feet dry

    When you find the dirt around uggs during your hiking, and you have to clean them. So firstly you need to find some water, like the lake. You began taking off your UGG cardy boots and started wiping the exterior using a brisk but soft motion to free your boots off excess dirt.

    Quality or real Timberland boots are designed with double-faced sheepskin that will ease your feet with comfort Timberland boot sale.Timberland boots sale are originating in America, Timberland sale it is made of sheepskin and trademarked chukka boots shoes name for the Timberland boots brand. Along with new timberland boots can be expensive like other designer fashions, many people cant afford to them but like them very much, Timberland boots sale so it turns out that a lot of them try to save money by buying cheap Timberland boots. This article will help to Learn how to Recognize fake Timberland boots online so you are not duped and save your dollars.

    You can be careful while buying timberlands:Timberland on sale1 Usually, the stitching quality and the finishing design of the fake Timberland boots cheap is very meager when compared to the real ones. You can identify counterfeit boots by looking at the soles and logos. Soles of fake timberlands are extremely rigid while women’sroll-top boots the soles of the real ones are highly flexible or Men timberlands.Every Nike Dunk, not just includes a two-color top, but in addition possesses a two-textured basic as well. The side sections, Nike Shoes Sale toe field as well as collar region are generally carried out up in suede, while the remainder of the base includes pebbled leather-based. Additionally, each and every Nike shoes also has a different shoelace color that will unquestionably gives each one sneaker a get noticed look.

    So are you excited already with all these new updates coming about Nike Dunk SB High? I am sure you are glad to hear about this especially if you are a Nike Dunk SB shoes fan.

    Recently, we have seen a couple of Air Max nike shoes samples. All of these
    Nike Air Max Shoes sale have been nice, but none were as good as the one you see here. Take a look at this Nike Air Max 90 , as it comes in a dark army colorway. This Nike Air Max 90 Current is finished off with a clean white midsole and a white/dark army outsole. Do you like them?

    Nike shox shoes are one of the best shoes in nike brand.Today I verry happy,because we can provide all kinds of series nike running Shoes and other cheap nike trainers shoes for Nike trainers online,
    Nike running shoes and keep updating our stock with new colors and styles.
    With the world’s best workmanship and most fashionable design,these Nike Shox Shoes are very popular with the masses.These Nike shox shoes offer comfort and a beautifully delicate design. Nike trainers shoes You will love this
    sleek and comfortable Shox shoes which is your gotta-have Nike shox shoes on sale.

    Pure Ghd Iv hair straighteners sales. have big surprise for mother’s day!It is really a wonderful nwes for us.
    hair straighteners sales We know that there are several days for mother’s day. As daughter, it is necessary for us to send a GHD straighteners for our mother.With excellent features that are highly effective and efficient colorful ghd gold hair straighteners,such as purple ghd strairhteners,
    GHD straighteners sales came to fulfill the trendy youth culture, allowing them to create ringlets BOSE headphones discount, frizzy, straight, curls and many more to their hair.CHI iron straightens my hair! I have coarse, curly, bushy hair that only straightened with a large round brush and blowdryer. With
    cheap CHI iron this Cheap CHI flat iron I just wash, air dry then straigten.Now there are many
    CHI iron sales online ,if you like ,you will buy them CHI iron sales.

    This is MBT shoes shop! The shop sale for MBT men shoes and MBT women shoes .Today I would like to talk about two kinds of MBT shoes for you.First ,is MBT Chapa GTX.The MBT Chapa GTX feature rich nubuck leather with single-layer mesh upper bodies
    for strong but breathable wear.
    Mbt chapa shoes are absolutely the best choice for winter! To simulate the collection.The other is MBT Changa. MBT Changa features two adjustable buckled straps and threaded contrast ribbon accents.Our online soccer store caters to all sizes and styles of player including men’s soccer footwear,Soccer Shoes and youth soccer cleats for kids and children. From the serious hardcore soccer player’s professional soccer shoes to the weekend casual soccer shoe, you’ll find it at
    SoccerPro is a registered authorized retailer for Cheap Soccer Shoes and accessories. Get into the newest styles off the line such as the Nike Superfly or the Nike CTR 360 soccer shoes. If you like the more classic shoes, perhaps you should stick with the Nike Total 90 collection or the Nike Talaria series. Nike Soccer Shoes sale are also pleased to bring you the latest in Nike Soccer Shoes cleat technology with the select Nike Mercurials, specifically designed for the female soccer player in mind.

    We are also a licensed reseller of Adidas Soccer Shoes, and have all the latest styles in stock. SoccerPro offers a wide selection of the latest Adidas Soccer Shoes sale cleats and the most recent release of the Adidas Predator series for the serious soccer athlete. We also offer more classic Adidas soccer cleat designs such as the Adidas Copa Mundial and Adidas Sambas.

  4. qinqin says:

    Shanghai World Expo 2010 opened soon in China, Xinhua News Agency,
    Shanghai, April 19 -, Seen everywhere from the "Treasure" to the
    cultural venues in the fiery show rehearsal, and links of london jewelry
    as one of the exhibits to show the world, links of london of various
    styles, quality assurance, excellent after-sales service, product style,
    the perfect combination of fashion and classic, elegant and noble, all
    have a unique display of personalized beauty.Shanghai World Expo will be
    opened, many cities in the Yangtze River Delta, full of atmosphere
    imbued with a deep sense of the Expo, the Government and the private and
    links of london sale are
    ready to welcome the event in preparation for the Expo. With the song
    "Wisteria" melody sounded a dozen actors tread the rhythm dance,
    choreographers sometimes provide guidance carefully. Each actor wore links
    of london bracelet
    , this is the 15th journalist in Jiangyin City,
    Jiangsu Province Museum rehearsal room to see the scenes, around the
    Yangtze River Delta is also preparing for the Expo show in
    microcosm.Song of the dancers, "Wisteria" is Jiangyin prepared for the
    World Expo 13 full of local flavor of the original one of the programs
    will be on board during the Shanghai Expo .At the same time, the Expo
    staff will be the best prepared for the Shanghai Expo. And Shanghai's
    neighboring cities have also strained, and efficient in doing
    preparatory work for the opening of the country .People are looking
    forward to the 2010 World Expo in Shanghai, like links of
    london rings
    , to us, to show the world the beauty of its beauty!

  5. Most of the inexpensive SEO packages are merely search engine marketing
    services which use software for the automatic entry of your own websites to numerous
    search engines like google, some thing which is useless.
    This is only because search engines aren’t capable of
    attracting targeted traffic to your website, and that means you
    should concern yourself with the main search engines.
    Your site does not have to be filed to any internet search
    engine as it could finally be indexed through the backlinks
    that the SEO expert has gained for you.

  6. our website says:

    Hi i am kavin, its my first occasion to commenting anywhere, when i read this post i thought i could also create comment due to this good article.

  7. learn more says:

    A lot of our company may possess commercial passions while buying or using electricity mopeds however, for little ones, electricity bikes are nothing
    lower than a luxury. The idea of electrical bike has been made
    solely for children. The conventional grow older for little ones to use the gas/electric
    scooters is 8 years. Nonetheless, the age could vary baseding on the little one’s
    body weight as well as maturity amount.

  8. Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though
    you relied on the video to make your point. You obviously know
    what youre talking about, why throw away your intelligence
    on just posting videos to your site when you could be giving us something informative to read?

  9. Hmm is anyone else encountering problems with the pictures on this blog loading?
    I’m trying to figure out if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
    Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

  10. next says:

    This piece of writing is in fact a fastidious one
    it helps new internet people, who are wishing for blogging.

  11. describes it says:

    I’m impressed, I must say. Seldom do I come across a blog that’s both educative and
    engaging, and without a doubt, you’ve hit the
    nail on the head. The issue is something that too few people are speaking intelligently about.
    Now i’m very happy I found this in my hunt for something concerning this.

  12. Excellent blog here! Also your site loads up very fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my site loaded up as fast as yours lol

  13. image source says:

    At this time it looks like WordPress is the top blogging platform available
    right now. (from what I’ve read) Is that what you’re using on your blog?

  14. That is really attention-grabbing, You are an overly skilled blogger.
    I have joined your feed and look forward to in search
    of more of your excellent post. Also, I’ve shared
    your website in my social networks

  15. news says:

    Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as
    I provide credit and sources back to your weblog?
    My blog is in the exact same niche as yours and my visitors would really benefit from some of the
    information you provide here. Please let me know if
    this okay with you. Thank you!

  16. There isn’t any single solution but tons of options –
    like I stated in the start, there’s no hard and speedy manual which states to the idea answers
    into all of your problems. Now in case you introduce a specific problem to some panel of experts,
    you are certain to receive many different comments and alternatives at return. This can turnout to
    be vexing.

  17. With havin so much content do you ever run into any issues of plagorism
    or copyright infringement? My blog has a lot of exclusive content I’ve either authored
    myself or outsourced but it appears a lot of it is
    popping it up all over the internet without my permission. Do you
    know any ways to help prevent content from being stolen? I’d really appreciate it.

  18. Appreciate you sharing, great blog article.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Website by Radish Lab.