Center for Media Justice home of the Media Action Grassroots Network

Inequalities in urban Internet service prop up social inequalities

Guest blog by, Marcos Martinez of Entre Hermanos.

The message couldn't have been more clear last month when FCC staff sat in a crowded Seattle conference room with about 80 local folks, gathered to share our opinions on preserving a fair and open Internet.

Click to listen to the presentation Marcos made during the FCC "Protecting a Fair and Open Internet" community forum.

Even in the tech capital of Seattle, urban communities need broadband access that is more fair, more affordable, and more reliable—and we need consumer protections from Internet providers who would keep many of us stuck in Internet slow lanes rather than treating us all fairly.


This summer, the FCC is making a sensible move to strengthen its ability to improve Internet access across the country, in response to a recent court decision which questioned the agency's authority to hold companies like Comcast accountable to our community needs. FCC Chairman Julius Genachowksi wants to make sure that the agency remains able to pursue the goals laid out in the National Broadband Plan released earlier this year; those goals include preserving Internet openness (net neutrality), and catching up with other industrialized countries in broadband speed and affordability.

Among the most important goals in that report is establishing broadband as a universal service. It's no secret that huge digital divides still exist between Internet haves and have-nots, as broadband access has been especially slow to reach many rural and tribal areas. But many urban areas are also afflicted by access problems—including some of the nation's supposed high-tech Meccas.

Few readers of Forbes were surprised last year when the business magazine ranked Seattle the nation's most tech-savvy city. Seattle is the center of a famously tech-rich area, with major software, high-tech and Internet-focused companies based in the region, and a high degree of utilization of information technologies ranging from smart phones to computers and cable television. In addition, the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis has ranked Seattle 17th in per capita income among 363 metropolitan areas, and the city also boasts among the highest rates of literacy and post-secondary graduates in the nation.

All this makes the persistence of digital divides in Seattle confounding and unsettling.

City government and community organizations have been engaged in studying the problem, and the city has created initiatives to close the gap and also researching the size and shape of the divide. The 2009 Seattle Technology Access and Adoption Report tracks the use of information technologies over time, and documents the digital divide.

“In an increasingly digital culture, the gap in [broadband] adoption threatens greater exclusion or marginalization, and sharper disparities in opportunities for education, civic participation, jobs and economic success.”

The city’s study was conducted using surveys and focus groups. Income and education were the most significant factors in determining digital exclusion, but age, ethnicity, language spoken and disability also were found  to be significant in technology adoption.  Focus groups conducted with immigrant communities also affirmed that those with language barriers are more disconnected.

One of the important uses of information technology in terms of civic affairs is the accessing of information about city services, policy-making and the opportunity to engage with elected or appointed officials. The city of Seattle, as an example, has an info-rich municipal website where users can not only pay their utility bills and report pot holes, but also send a message directly to the mayor, find out when a transportation planning meeting is taking place, and comment on policy issues that affect their daily living.

While the internet has many uses that are entertaining and could be considered frivolous, the ability to engage civically is one use where the exclusion of certain demographic groups can affect our democracy. If low-income residents are unable to access important services and information online, they are shut out of important opportunities to wield their civic power.

In addition, the success of students is increasingly determined by access to the information and resources that are available online, and which depend on the ability to connect at high speeds. Many low-income households in Seattle remain unable to afford home Internet access–that affects students' ability to complete homework, and parents' ability to communicate with teachers.

In the same way that policymakers implemented Universal Service for telephones in the last century, a similar initiative is needed today to insure that disparities of income and opportunity do not deepen the disenfranchisement of groups that are excluded from the digital revolution. We've got to make sure that the federal government, including the FCC, continues to follow this path.

In Seattle, our local Digital Justice Coalition, led by Reclaim the Media and other MAG-Net member organizations, is calling for both local and national solutions for expanding digital rights. We're pushing our city government to build a publicly-owned fiber broadband network, in order to provide affordable, fast broadband to every home/office in Seattle. This build-it-ourselves solution would go a long way towards erasing local digital divides, equalizing technology access across neighborhoods for the first time. In addition, a publicly-accountable open network would guarantee open access and net neutrality

But for the long term, federal policies are needed to protect our digital rights–not just in tech centers like Seattle, but in all urban and rural communities. That's why MAG-Net member organizations across the country are continuing to push the FCC and our elected officials to enact policies that make high-quality broadband access truly universal, maintain a fair and open Internet, and encourage all people to become fully engaged participants in our digital democracy.

Marcos Martinez is executive director of Entre Hermanos, a nonprofit devoted to HIV prevention in Seattle's Latino community. He is also board president of the Minority Executive Directors Coalition, and a board member of the Youth Media Institute. Marcos was a featured speaker at Reclaim the Media's April community forum with the FCC, "Protecting a Fair and Open Internet."


About the Author


  1. echo says:

    for replica designer handbags on sale it. I��m always a Chloe IT Edith Bags sale big fan of ��slouchy�� cheap designer bags bags��and I love how designer bags online the Gucci Sukey Large designer handbags wholesale Tote has just the designer handbags discount right amount of ��give.�� It��s stable enough to stand up on a tabletop, but definitely not stiff. I a

  2. greedyisgood says:

    Costs should drop as GM sells Costs should drop as GM sells wedding gown more Volts, and should be substantially lower after eight years, Stephens said. He Wedding Gown Dress said used batteries can be shipped to GM to be rebuilt to extend their lives. Customers also would have the option fake Louis Vuitton of disposing of them, he said. more Volts, and should be substantially lower louis vuitton wallet for women after eight years, Stephens said. He said used batteries can be shipped to GM to be rebuilt to louis vuitton wallet men extend their lives. Customers also would have the option of disposing of them, he said.

  3. wyxx says:

    Many people want to buy diamonds do not know how the determination of the value of the diamond links of london links of London available online. Here you will find a great variety of jewelry such as links of london jewellery links of London sweetie bracelet collect links of London necklace。She would wear it links london when she went out on her bicycle. Outside, Ailsa smiled. which has links london wholesale evolved into the center of the world as Fashion jewelry making industry links jewellery the kind of day Ailsa liked best. She climbed on her bicycle and links of london bracelet headed downtown to do some shopping

  4. wyxx says:

    Everyteenagercould links of london existing freely once you buy their significance links of london sweetie bracelet It has fulfilled the fantasy and entreaty of all ladies in the relations London, the best promotion excellent silver jewels, forever links of london sweetie sells very securely once it is very thrilled to collect links of London necklace. Then come to coo links for delicate links of london necklaces Necklace inspired jewelries with the theme of love & brilliant and thoughtful men.

  5. wyxx says:

    links jewelry < reflects the cultural birthright links of london of the African’s people, and a deep amazement for nature. This plain and stylish links of London charm jewelry is often blending of exoticism, elegance, and quality.links of London technical skill over centuries; links rings, Cowries and hemp necklaces, links of London links of london jewellery earrings, bracelets and other charms are meticulously handcrafted in links of London store which has evolved into the center of the world as Fashion jewelry links of london rings making industry.Heart-shaped black bracelet friendship-It is made of sterling silver, colors and flower designs. This bracelet is of free size to fits on all medium sized wrists.Young generation not only girls but boy’s too loved links jewelry very much. Even a couple of strategically placed African cowries in a links necklace or bracelet add immeasurable interest and excitement.

  6. pdambc163 says:

    Thanks for sharing.

    farmville cheats

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Website by Radish Lab.